More consumers are ignoring promotional emails because they cannot verify whether the messages are genuine, with 43% saying they deleted or abandoned an email over authenticity concerns in the past year, according to a DigiCert survey released ahead of the Black Friday shopping season.
The study found that 17% of consumers delayed a purchase because they doubted an email’s authenticity, while more than 1 in 10 chose to shop with another retailer.
Only 3% of respondents said they would open or click a promotional offer if they could not verify that it came from the brand. More than half said they would delete, ignore or report the message.
The survey also found that nearly 90% of consumers received a suspicious email in the past year, and 42% took some form of action in response. Delivery companies were the most frequently impersonated organizations, with more than half of suspicious-email recipients reporting messages claiming to come from a delivery provider.
The timing of these messages can make them convincing during the holiday shopping season. Nearly 3 in 10 consumers said they partly judge an email’s authenticity by whether they are expecting it, making fake delivery notifications harder to distinguish from legitimate updates.
Among consumers who received suspicious emails, 63% of those in the United Kingdom encountered messages impersonating delivery companies, the highest proportion among the countries surveyed. In the United States, 45% said they received suspicious emails frequently.
Despite growing awareness of online fraud, confidence in identifying scams does not always translate into safer behavior.
Seven in 10 consumers believed they could recognize a professionally written scam email, but 38% still relied on spelling and grammar to assess authenticity. The study noted that AI-generated fraudulent messages can bypass these checks.
The gap was particularly evident among consumers aged 25 to 34. While 82% said they were confident they could identify scam emails, 59% had clicked a link, made a payment or shared personal information before realizing a message was fraudulent.
DigiCert’s research also found that visible verification can influence purchasing decisions. Fifty-four percent of consumers said they would choose a brand displaying its official logo in their email inbox over a competitor, up from 49% in 2025.
Consumers shown a retail email with a verified logo were more likely to buy than those shown the same message without one. Three-quarters said the logo made them feel safer. However, 40% of respondents were unaware that verified inbox logos existed, rising to 48% in Germany.
Concerns about authenticity also extend to online product listings. More than one-third of consumers said they had decided not to buy something because they were unsure whether an image or video was genuine. A quarter said this uncertainty had reduced their trust in retailers.
The survey found that product images carrying credentials that establish their origin were more likely to earn consumer trust and encourage purchases. At checkout, half of respondents said a trust mark confirming who operates a website would make them more likely to complete a transaction.
Al Iverson, industry research and community engagement lead at Valimail, a DigiCert company, said retailers needed to make legitimate communications easier to identify.
“Shoppers shouldn’t have to play detective every time an offer lands in their inbox,” Iverson said. “Retailers can help by making their emails harder to impersonate and easier to recognize.”
DigiCert and Valimail cited Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting and Conformance (DMARC) as one way brands can protect their email domains. The policy tells email providers how to handle messages that impersonate a brand’s domain. While monitoring policies can identify suspicious activity, enforcement is needed to reject fraudulent messages.
The companies also offer DigiCert Mark Certificates, which enable participating inboxes to display verified brand logos to help recipients recognize legitimate emails.
The independent survey was conducted by Vitreous World on behalf of DigiCert in October 2026. It covered 6,000 consumers aged 18 and older: 2,000 in the United States, 2,000 in the United Kingdom, 1,000 in Germany, 800 in Australia and 200 in New Zealand.
The year-over-year comparison on brand preference used respondents from the four markets included in both surveys, excluding Germany, which was added in 2026.






Leave a Reply